Our menu

Made from scratch. 
baked fresh. everyday.

Our products are made from scratch daily, using only the finest ingredients at our original location on the corner of Galena & Cooper. We’re baking cookies, muffins & brownies continuously throughout the day, so you always get that “hot from the oven” experience. Our gelato has also become a favorite and Paradise is the only location in town making it from scratch. If it’s liquid refreshment you’re craving, our homemade lemonade is made fresh daily and our Paradise Blend Coffee and espresso is always brewing.

Download complete menu



There’s a reason we’ve been “famous for our cookies since 1976,” but you should really stop by and taste for yourself.

We offer ten cookie flavors to satisfy any crowd:

Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip, Sugar, Snickerdoodle, Black Diamond, Ginger Molasses, Lemon Zester, Oatmeal Raisin, White Chocolate Macadamia and Caramel Pecan

We also offer bite-sized cookies widely known as “Chippers” in three flavors–Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Sugar and Black Diamond.

For the gluten-free crowd, we are happy to announce that we have a Gluten Free Chocolate Chip Cookie. Many people say it’s the best gluten free chocolate chip cookie ever–even better than the original!



Our muffins can be the perfect partner to your morning coffee, or a tasty trail treat for that post hike reward.

Fresh muffin flavors available:

Blueberry, Banana Chocolate Chip, Mandarin Orange, Cinnamon Apple Streusel, Pumpkin Nut, Zucchini Nut, Banana Nut and Bran with Raspberries

We also take great pride in our Gluten Free options Lemon Poppyseed and Morning Glory. We believe they’re every bit as good as our original flavors. Good news vegans, the Morning Glory is vegan too!


Brownies and Bars

Loaded with delicious chocolate and topped with a fudge frosting, our brownies are as rich as they look. We guarantee they will satisfy even the most intense chocolate craving.

Our brownie and bar options are:

Traditional Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Cream Cheese Brownie, Blondie, Raspberry Bar and Carrot Cake



Light and flaky, both our classic and filled croissants are the perfect complement to our baked goods when you’re in the mood for the classic French pastry.

Our croissant flavors are:

Butter, Chocolate, Ham and Cheddar, Turkey and Swiss, Spinach, Almond, Blueberry Cream Cheese, Cherry, Apple

Our incredible Cinnamon Rolls are another breakfast treat that will satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you craving more.


Breakfast Burritos and Quiches

Start your day with an energy boost with our new breakfast burritos! Bacon, ham or spinach with eggs, green chili, cheddar cheese, potatoes and black beans in a flour tortilla.

Looking for something savory to get your day started? Our homemade quiche muffins are an incredible alternative to the bakery’s bounty of sweet options and they are gluten-free too!  Try the quiche with Spinach or with Ham.


Gelato and Sorbetto

Our homemade Gelato has become famous both in town and beyond, and it’s as popular in the cold winter months as it is during our warm summer nights.

Some of our gelato flavors include Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Cappuccino Toffee Crunch, Black Diamond Cookies and Cream, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Fudge Brownie, Mint Chocolate Flake and Butter Pecan.

Whip up a delicious Milkshake in any of the flavors available or mix-and-match to make your own creation!

We offer five sorbetto options as well–gluten-free, dairy-free and vegan: Lemon, Pink Grapefruit, Blueberry, Mango and Peach.

Now serving flights of gelato, 6 flavors of the perfect assortment to share with your BFF!!
Gelato Menu


Coffee and Espresso

A light and a dark roast with a balanced flavor, our coffee is brewed continually throughout the day so you’ll always get a fresh cup of coffee to pair with our baked goods or on its own.

We have a wide variety of espresso drinks, chai latte, apple cider and other hot and cold drink options to satisfy your mood.

Join our loyalty program to get the best value while staying local.



Made every morning with heaps of lemons and a little bit of muscle, our classic lemonade is fresh squeezed, and as simple and refreshing as it gets.



Cookie Cakes, Gelato Cookie Cakes and Catering Trays

Looking to cater your next party with Paradise?  From giant cookies for special occasions to a tray of cookies and brownies for your office party, we have a range of options for all event sizes.

Our Giant Cookies come in 12″ and 8″ sizes in any cookie flavor and we need 2 hours notice. We also make Gelato Cookie Cakes with 24 flavors of Gelatos to choose from and 24 hours notice.

Some of our standard catering trays are the Breakfast Tray for 12 people with assorted breakfast items and the Brownie and Chippers Tray, a very popular Thank You gift.

Complete your event catering with our Joe-to-Go containers of Coffee, Hot Chocolate and Apple Cider, to serve 12-15 people each.

Contact us for more information